What a missed service call actually costs your shop
Most shop owners under-count this. Ask a three-truck plumbing operation in a metro like Hamilton what a missed call costs and the answer is usually "fifty bucks maybe." Do the math against the same shop's actual numbers and it's typically closer to four hundred. The story repeats across plumbing, HVAC, electrical, and roofing because the underlying math doesn't change.
The miss isn't a single missed call. It's the chain of things that happens after the miss.
What you're not counting
The standard mental model is: missed call equals lost job. Lost job equals lost ticket. Lost ticket is whatever the average ticket size is, maybe $200, maybe $400, maybe $800.
That's the floor. It's almost always wrong because it leaves out three things.
First, the cost of the lead itself. If you're running Google Ads on "emergency plumber Mississauga," every click you bought already cost money. A shop running Google Ads on emergency-plumber terms in a competitive metro typically pays $40+ per click. If a quarter of those clicks ring through and miss, every fourth click is a $40+ charge with zero revenue against it.
Second, the lifetime value. A homeowner who calls you for a drain cable today is the same homeowner who'll call for a water heater swap in four years and probably refer her neighbor next spring. Lose her once and you lose all of that. Service-business LTV is meaningfully bigger than the first ticket for any trade with repeat-call patterns, which is most of them.
Third, the operating cost of the alternative. A lot of owners pay a part-time receptionist or pay a service or build an after-hours rotation, all of which are spending money to NOT lose those calls. That's a real cost line that lives in the same column as missed-call losses.
The math, by trade
The numbers below are illustrative, built from public ticket-size data and conversations with shop owners in the trades. Use them as a worksheet template against your own books, not as quoted statistics.
Plumbing
Average residential ticket: $250-$800 depending on the job. LTV note: meaningful multi-year value when the homeowner becomes a repeat customer, harder to put a single number on without a specific shop's data. Common call types missed in residential plumbing: routine drain clears plus after-hours leaks, with water heater inquiries close behind.
Walk through a typical month for a 3-truck shop. Inbound calls land somewhere in the 200-300 range. Conservative miss rate is 25%, so roughly 50-75 missed calls a month. Assume half of those callers go to another plumber. The lost revenue, at $400 average ticket, is $10,000-$15,000 in the first month alone before LTV.
The most expensive missed call in this category is the after-hours leak. Homeowner sees water somewhere it shouldn't be, panics, dials the first number that comes up. If you don't pick up, the next plumber gets a customer who's been pre-qualified as motivated to buy.
HVAC
Average residential ticket: $300-$1,500 depending on whether it's a service call, repair, or replacement. Busy season: roughly 8-10 weeks split between peak summer and the first cold snap.